Fandom Classics by Star Rating

With the list of complete 6-star fics left to review nearly at zero, I'm moving on to other well-known, highly regarded MLP fanfics.  The list below is of the Fandom Classics I've reviewed to date.  It's a manually updated list, but I'll try to remember to update every couple weeks or so.  Stories are sorted by star rating; links are to my reviews.

If you're looking for a list of upcoming fanfics to be reviewed, check here.  This list is compiled by me, with an eye to breaking up different lengths and genres of stories (e.g. not putting four long stories back-to-back-to-back, not having a month straight of random comedy, etc.).  However, the stories which make it up are almost all reader-recommended.  If you have a suggestion for a popular fanfic which you'd like to see me review, please e-mail me at madethisjusttopostponies@gmail.com.  I'm always open to further recommendations!


 
Princess Celestia Hates Tea,
by Skywriter
Apotheosis, by Daetrin
The Song of Syhlex, by The Descendant
Salvation, by Cold in Gardez



A Drop of Moonshine, by Pen Stroke
The Glass Blower, by Cold in Gardez
The Archer and the Smithby Sharaloth
Brony Hero of Equestria, by Blueshift
Whom the Princesses Would Destroy, by GhostOfHeraclitus
Variables, by The Descendant
Somewhere Only We Know, by PatchworkPoltergeist
Friendship is Optimal, by Iceman
The Games We Play, by AbsoluteAnonymous
Equestria From Dust, by Soundslikeponies
Integration, by Raugos
The Celestia Code, by iisaw
No Regrets, by horizon
The Dresden Fillies: Strange Friends, by psychicscubadiver
The Writing on the Wall, by Horse Voice
Yes, Apple Bloom, there *is* a Santa Hooves, by Lucky Dream
Stardust, by Arad
A Draconequus' Guide to Immortality, by Argonmatrix
Pinkie Watches Paint Dry, by AbsoluteAnonymous
All the Mortal Remains, by Cold in Gardez
The Star In Yellow, by Blueshift
In Memory Of, by Obselescence
Flash Fog, by Kwackerjack
Twice as Bright, by Cloudy Skies
Schemering Sintel, by N00813
The Witch of the Everfree, by MagnetBolt
Martial Bliss, by Skywriter
Post Negative Comments Only, by Estee
Statistics, by xTSGx
Binky Pie, by Miyajima
The Mare Who Once Lived on the Moon, by MrNumbers



No Quixote Here, by RedSquirrel456
Mendacity, by Dromicosuchus
"For I am a Jelly God," by Posh
Pipsqueak's Day Off, by Chuckfinley
A Candle to the Sun, by Moabit
Bureaucracy is Magic, by Pen Stroke
Daring DONE!, by Aragon
Wingmares, by CouchCrusader
The Fires of Friendship, by Ponydora Prancypants
Fallout Equestria: Pink Eyes, by mimezinga
The Age of Wings and Steel, by DSNesmith
The Sky is Falling, by Bronius Maximus
Let's Just Say..., by Obselescense
Wonderbolt, by WovenWord
Fiddlesticks!, by Tigerhorse
The Irony of Applejack, by Mister Friendly
What You Can Imagine, by Darf
Synchronicity, by A Hoof-ful of Dust
On the Importance of Spelling, by Softly8088
Quizzical, by JMac
Twilight's List, by kits
The Last Human: Tales of the Pre-Classical Era, by PatchworkPoltergeist
Roll For Initiative, by Prak
Do Changelings Dream of Herding Sheep?, by John Perry
Petriculture, by Kwackerjack
One Last Quest, by Vanner
The Appledash Project, by bookplayer
Words Failed Her, by Nonsanity
Iron Hearts: Book 1--Planetfall, by SFAccountant
Without a Hive, by Phoenix_Dragon
The Haunting in Ponyville, by JasonTheHuman
Newsworthy, by _Medicshy
Mortality Report, by Bad Horse
The Monster in the Twilight, by Georg
Night Guards, by Raugos
Awakening, by Solocitizen
Boast Busted, by RainbowDoubleDash
Regarding the Need for Sex Education, by GAPJaxie
The Moon, the Flower, and the Door, by Bucking Nonsense
Twilight Sparkle Gets a Free Salad, by AestheticB
Dying to Get There, by Titanium Dragon
Princess Twilight Sparkle's 500th Birthday, by Autumnschild
And the Temptress Came Unto Her, by Device Heretic
Sun Princess, by Skywriter
Dear Idiot, by The Descendent
Whip and Wing, by Fernin
A Teacher With No Class, by Kavonde
The Brightest and the Best, by Pineta
Changeling Courtship Rituals, by Codex Ex Equus
Forever and Again and Again, by Titanium Dragon
Friendship Is Optimal: Caelum est Conterrens, by Chatoyance



White Box, by Chromosome
Once Bitten, Twice Shy, by Wynneception
Of Mares and Magic, by GanonFLCL
This Nearly was Mine, by BillyColt
Distorted Perspective, by Vimbert the Unimpressive
As Celestia Is My Witness, by Adcoon
Princess Celestia Gets Mugged, by BronyWriter
A Novel Tale, by Blissey1
Sepia Tock: Adventures of a Ponyville Clockmaker, by CanvasWolfDoll
Thrown Abroad, by Niaeruzu
Twilight Sparkle: Night Shift, by JawJoe
Vinyl and Octavia: University Days, by Dawnfade
In Celestia We Trust, All Others Pay Cash, by Georg
Forever is Forever, by Fon Shaolin
The Sisters Doo, by Ponky
The Assumption of Applejack -or- Appletheosis, by Blue Print
Melt, by Ambion
In Her Majesty's Royal Service, by Sagebrush
Letters from a Friends at the End of the World, by Alexmagnet
Cracked Beauty, by Slate Sadpony
Believing Stories, by Typewritererror
One in a Million, by ocalhoun
Scootaling, by GrassandClouds2
The Brief Reign of Princess Twily, by Forthwith
Changelings, Changelings Everywhere, by Benman
What I've Become, by Knight Breeze
Of Apples and Roses and Thick Purple Proses, by RavensDagger
Canterlot Cantata, by Ringcaat
A Night (to Try) to Remember, by Zaptiftun
Scootaloo's Parents, by Carmine
I Look Into The Flames And See, by Tramper
A Finer Vintage, by Sunchaser
Ascend, by xTSGx
Voyage's End, by The DM
Loyalty, by Arbarano
The Sun & the Rose, by soulpillar
Pinkie Pie is an Eldrich Abomination, by PonyAmorous
Upheaval: Breaking Point, by Visiden Visidane
Arrow 18 Mission Logs: Lone Ranger, by AdmiralTigerclaw
A Perfectly Ordinary Day in Ponyville, by The Equestrian Gentlecolt
Living Forever..., by Whateverdudezb
Insomnia, by Pale Horse
The Assassination of Twilight Sparkle, by Rated Ponystar
Applejack's Tax Relief Plan, by Seether00
A Great and Powerful Heart, by Deep Pond
Light the Sky on Fire, by EquesTRON
A FLEet|ng LIght |n thE DArknEsS, by fFashgen
Fire Spores, by applecinnamonspice 
There, They're, by FanNotANerd
A Pony Walks Into a Bar..., by chief maximus
Let's Find You a Date!, by Soundslikeponies
Keeping Your Hooves on the Ground, by InsertAuthorHere



Arddun Lleuad, by Pride
Smoke and Mirrors, by TeaPartyCannon
The Combinatorics Project, by Ringcaat
My Roommate is a Vampire, by Dennis the Menace
Hiccups, by shortskirtsandexplosions
The Golden Armor, by Comet Burst
How to Preen Your Chicken, by Drakkith
Spitfire's Day Off, by Artimae
Who We Are, by Kits
Mood Wings, by Tchernobog
What's Eating Rainbow Dash?, by Somber
Of Age, by paleowriter
Minuette's Lesson, by Airstream
Post Nuptials, by Darth Link 22
Foal of the Forest, by moguera
Project: Sunflower, by Hoopy McGee
Best Young Flyer, by Bookplayer
A Dream of Dawn, by Starsong
The Longest Night, by Tundara
Life on the Frontier, by Starwind Dood
Dash's New Mom, by ABagOVicodin
Twilight Sparkle Earns the Feature-Box, by Skywriter
Rainbooms and Royalty, by Trinary
Forever Faithful, by Konseiga
Inner Demons, by SapphireLibra3
Forever Young, by Hyperexponential
Still a Better Love Story than Twilight, by meme-asaurus
To Be a Better Stallion, by Autumn Wind
The Elements of Harmony and the Savior of Worlds, by RK_Striker_JK_5
A Joke too Far, by ZOMG
A Simpler Time, by DJLowrider
The 63rd Rune, by Alextrazsa
Heart to Heart, by Crosis
Magical Pony Lyrical Twilight, by Purple Prose
Pirates for a Day, by Dawnfade
Tyrant, by PaulAsaran
I'd Do Her, by Fire Gazer the Alchemist
Would It Matter If I Was?, by GaPJaxie
A little loopy., by warewolves
Fluttershy and Celestia Play Chess, by Bronywriter
The Cough, by Ebon Mane
Why am I Crying?, by Rated Ponystar
The Three Sisters, by Wanderer D
Arachnophobia, by Dennis the Menace
Rarity Loses Her Innocence In a Poker Game, by MrNumbers
Gods-In-Law, by Pearple Prose
The Party Hasn't Ended, by Butterscotchsundae
Princess Celestia? Do You Have a Belly Button?, by Foals Errand
Pretty In Pink, by David Reinold
Veil of Thoughts, by Starwin
Scion of Chaos, by SilentBelle
Applejack's Bar, by Alaborn
The Ballad of Echo the Diamond Dog, by Rust
Couchtavia, by shortskirtsandexplosions
The Parliament of Dreams, by Wheller
Fun With Changelings, by Shukumei
Evil Belle, by Akumokagetsu
It's Not Like I'm Deaf, by Arreis of Avalon
The Incredibly Dense Mind of Rainbow Dash, by Chengar Qordath
Gazing to the Ocean of the Sky, by David Silver
The Eagle Has Landed, by Cyanblackstone
A Change in Three Parts, by GaPJaxie
Celestia's Prophet, by Aegis Shield
Winds of Change, by Masterweaver
A True, True Friend?, by Blazewing
Negotiations, by Rated Ponystar
Nosflutteratu, by Charcoal Quill
Twilight Hears the Narrator, by Stratocaster
Exit Through Canterlot, by TheBrianJ
Luna, There's a Sentient Race Inside Your Mane, by boardgamebrony